Every year, law firms spend a significant amount of time on legal rankings and awards, and Best Lawyers is one of the most recognizable names in the industry. Yet I regularly see confusion about how the process works, what firms can do to help their lawyers get recognized and how the different distinctions relate to each other.

There’s Best Lawyers, Ones to Watch, Lawyer of the Year, Best Law Firms and Law Firm of the Year. Then there are national and regional rankings, different practice areas and multiple tiers. It’s easy to see why lawyers and marketing teams sometimes treat them as parts of the same process, even though there are important differences in how each recognition is determined. Understanding those differences matters because the strategy for getting an individual lawyer recognized is quite different from the work involved in positioning an entire practice for a firm ranking.

How Best Lawyers Actually Works

One of the biggest misconceptions about Best Lawyers is that firms can improve a lawyer’s chances of being ranked by preparing a particularly compelling nomination. Unlike Chambers or Legal 500, where firms invest considerable time developing submissions, describing representative matters and identifying client referees, Best Lawyers is primarily based on peer review.

A nomination puts a lawyer into consideration, but it doesn’t guarantee recognition. Submitting multiple nominations for the same lawyer doesn’t improve their chances either. The evaluation happens when other lawyers assess their peers.

Best Lawyers asks recognized lawyers to evaluate other lawyers in their practice area and geographic market, focusing on whether they would refer a matter to that individual if they couldn’t handle it themselves. This is an important distinction because the lawyers evaluating you need to know who you are, understand your practice and have enough confidence in your abilities that they would trust you with a client relationship.

You can be an excellent lawyer with an impressive client roster and still have limited recognition among your peers, particularly if most of your professional relationships are concentrated within your own firm or a small group of clients. That’s why I think lawyers should pay much more attention to the relationship-building side of Best Lawyers than the nomination process itself.

Your Professional Relationships Matter More Than Your Nomination

If you’re hoping to be recognized by Best Lawyers, start by thinking about how well known you are among lawyers outside your firm. Consider who knows your work, who would refer a client to you and which lawyers have worked across the table from you, collaborated with you on matters or seen you speak about your area of expertise.

These relationships develop through your everyday professional activities, including working with opposing counsel, collaborating with co-counsel, staying connected with former colleagues, participating in bar associations and attending industry conferences. Your writing and speaking activities can also help other lawyers understand your expertise. When you consistently share insights about the legal and business issues affecting your clients, you give people a clearer picture of the work you do and the areas in which you have experience.

LinkedIn can support this effort as well. Staying visible to former colleagues, referral sources and other lawyers in your practice area makes it easier to maintain relationships between in-person interactions. Sharing substantive content, commenting on industry developments and staying engaged with your professional network can help reinforce the expertise you want to be known for.

I also think lawyers underestimate the value of making referrals themselves. Building relationships with lawyers in complementary practices and other jurisdictions can create opportunities to collaborate and refer work over time. These are activities that support business development regardless of whether an award ever follows, and Best Lawyers recognition is one possible reflection of the professional reputation you’ve developed.

Why Participating in the Voting Process Matters

Another part of the process that deserves attention is peer voting. Lawyers who are already recognized by Best Lawyers are invited to evaluate their peers, yet these requests can easily get lost among the many emails lawyers receive.

If you’re eligible to participate, take the time to review the ballot and provide thoughtful feedback about lawyers whose work you know. Firms can help by making sure their recognized lawyers understand the voting process and deadlines, without trying to influence how they evaluate individual candidates.

There’s an important distinction between encouraging participation and attempting to coordinate votes. The credibility of a peer-review ranking depends on lawyers providing independent assessments based on their professional knowledge. For lawyers seeking recognition, this reinforces the importance of developing relationships with people who have firsthand experience with their work.

What Is Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch?

Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch recognizes lawyers earlier in their careers through a peer-review process similar to the traditional Best Lawyers recognition. I think this is an area where law firms have an opportunity to be much more proactive because too often, business development and external visibility become priorities only when lawyers are approaching partnership or have already made partner.

By that point, they may have spent years developing excellent technical skills without building much of a professional network outside the firm. Associates should begin developing their professional reputations much earlier through industry organizations, relationships with lawyers at other firms, writing, speaking and developing expertise in particular industries or areas of law.

It also means thinking about what they want to be known for professionally. A junior lawyer who is developing a practice in healthcare transactions, for example, can begin building relationships with others in that field well before becoming a partner. For marketing and business development teams, Ones to Watch provides another reason to include associates in external visibility and relationship-building initiatives. The recognition itself is valuable, but helping younger lawyers develop a stronger professional network can benefit them and the firm throughout their careers.

What Does Lawyer of the Year Actually Mean?

Lawyer of the Year is another distinction that can cause confusion, particularly when firms announce the recognition without explaining the practice area or geographic market. Lawyer of the Year is awarded to one lawyer in a particular practice area and metropolitan market based on especially strong peer feedback.

It’s not a separate award that firms can simply submit someone for, and it doesn’t mean the recipient was selected as the best lawyer in the country across an entire practice. For example, a lawyer recognized as Lawyer of the Year in a particular litigation practice in New York has received that distinction within that specific practice and metropolitan market.

That context matters when promoting the recognition. I always recommend using the complete award designation in website biographies, LinkedIn posts, press releases and other marketing materials because it provides a more accurate description of the achievement and helps clients and prospects understand what the recognition represents.

How Best Law Firms Rankings Are Different

Best Law Firms is where the process becomes more involved for law firm marketing and business development teams. While individual Best Lawyers recognition focuses primarily on peer evaluations, Best Law Firms considers a broader range of information about the practice, including feedback from clients and professional references and information provided by the firm. Individual lawyer recognition also plays a role in determining eligibility for particular practice areas and jurisdictions.

This is why firms need to approach Best Law Firms differently from individual Best Lawyers nominations. The information provided about a practice matters, and firms should be thoughtful about how they describe their capabilities, representative work, industry experience and the developments that distinguish the practice.

Client references are another important component. I think firms sometimes place too much emphasis on selecting their most recognizable clients when identifying references. A prominent client who has limited interaction with the lawyers may be less helpful than someone who works closely with the team and can speak knowledgeably about the quality of its advice, responsiveness and understanding of the client’s business.

This is also an area where marketing and business development professionals can add considerable value by coordinating submissions, working with practice leaders to identify the strongest matters and helping select appropriate references.

Understanding National and Regional Tiers

Best Law Firms rankings are organized by practice area and geography, with firms recognized in national and regional tiers. A National Tier 1 ranking and a Regional Tier 1 ranking are different distinctions, and both need to be described accurately.

When promoting these recognitions, firms should include the practice area, geographic designation and tier. Simply announcing that a firm has been named a “Tier 1 law firm” leaves out important context and can give readers an incomplete understanding of the recognition.

I also recommend making sure that the information is consistent across the firm’s website, attorney biographies, social media posts, email signatures and other marketing materials. These details may seem small, but accuracy matters when promoting third-party rankings.

What About Law Firm of the Year?

Law Firm of the Year is a separate distinction within the Best Law Firms program that recognizes one firm in a particular practice area. The evaluation considers a broader set of factors relating to the practice, including peer feedback, the firm’s history of recognition, significant matters and other information about its work.

It shouldn’t be confused with having the largest number of individually ranked lawyers. A firm may have many lawyers recognized by Best Lawyers, but that doesn’t automatically translate into Law Firm of the Year recognition. The distinction is intended to recognize the overall standing and strength of a particular practice.

What Lawyers and Law Firms Can Do to Improve Their Chances of Recognition

For individual lawyers, building a stronger professional reputation throughout the year should be a priority. Identify the practice areas and markets where you have established expertise and think about how well other lawyers in those areas know your work. Look for opportunities to develop relationships with former colleagues, co-counsel, referral sources and lawyers you meet through professional organizations and industry events.

Being intentional about your external visibility can also help. Writing, speaking, participating in industry groups and maintaining an active LinkedIn presence can help other lawyers understand your expertise. Consistency matters because professional reputations develop through repeated interactions over time.

For associates, firms should start earlier by helping promising younger lawyers build relationships and develop visibility in their chosen practice areas. Ones to Watch can be part of that effort, but the professional development benefits extend well beyond rankings.

For law firms, being selective and strategic about nominations is important. Focus on practice areas and geographic markets where lawyers have credible experience and an established or developing reputation. Nominating every eligible lawyer across numerous categories is unlikely to be an effective strategy.

For Best Law Firms, invest time in the submission and reference process. Work with practice leaders to identify significant matters, explain what makes the practice distinctive and select clients who can provide informed feedback about the team’s work.

Once recognition is received, firms should make better use of it by updating attorney biographies and practice pages, preparing LinkedIn posts, sharing relevant recognitions with clients and prospects when appropriate and incorporating rankings into pitches and proposals. Make sure the full award designation is accurate wherever it appears.

There’s also an opportunity to look at rankings as part of a broader business development strategy. If a lawyer is trying to build a practice in a particular industry or geographic market, the relationships and visibility activities supporting that effort can also strengthen their professional reputation among peers.

Why This Matters Beyond the Rankings

But I think the most important lesson is what the peer-review process tells us about professional reputation. Other lawyers need to know your work well enough to have confidence in your abilities. Clients need to have meaningful experiences with your team to provide informed feedback, and firms need to be able to communicate the strength of their practices through credible examples and relationships.

Those things develop through the work lawyers do every day, the relationships they maintain and the effort they put into becoming known for their expertise. If Best Lawyers recognition is something you’re working toward, pay attention to the nomination process and voting deadlines, but spend just as much time thinking about your professional network, your visibility and the reputation you’re building in your market. Those efforts can create business development opportunities whether or not your name appears on the next list.

Stay in Touch! Connect with me on LinkedIn,  Threads, YouTube, Instagram, sign up for my email list and follow my blog. Obtain a copy of my LinkedIn Secrets guide. Sign up for my LinkedIn Mastermind.